Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Making the Unpredictable Inevitable

As I make my daily internet check of the news headlines, of which the outbreak of Ebola and the brutal beheadings by ISIS followed by the subsequent renewal of perpetual American bombing are but the latest typical installments, I am now realizing that I can’t even imagine a potential major news event that would qualify unequivocally as good news. The only recent exception, and an exception exactly because its glad tidings were so unexpected, was the announcement by LeBron James that he would be returning to his hometown Cleveland Cavaliers after publicly jilting them four years prior in one of the biggest PR blunders of all time, pursuant to infamously “taking (his) talents to South Beach.” Perhaps there were just enough overtones of the Parable of the Prodigal Son to evoke that quintessential book of good news, the gospels. I would also venture that LeBron’s return to Cleveland qualifies as one of Alain Badiou’s events, which are described by Clayton Crockett and Jeffrey W. Robbins in Religion Politics, and the Earth thusly: “when a singular event occurs, it is an event, because there is something completely unpredictable or unforeseen, and it enables people to invent new ways of thinking and living in response.” Just so, LeBron’s return to Northeast Ohio from South Beach contains the radically new (for us) perspective that the best and most important place in the world is wherever one’s soul happens to be rooted. Before LeBron, moving from Northeast Ohio to South Beach and then, voluntarily, back again to Northeast Ohio was as unthinkable as reversing the flow of time. And while LeBron hasn’t reversed time, the event of LeBron’s return to Cleveland has shifted the flow of this particular river of spacetime that we call home in a slightly, but also noticeably better direction.

But outside of LeBron, the daily rundown of news headlines has begun to feel like a countdown to The End, each news item the tick of one more second off the fast expiring clock. When the news media, and the world, is experienced precisely this way, one particular piece of bad news mutates into the exception that proves the rule found in the inverse of “no news is good news,” i.e. all news is bad news. That exception, the bad news which gets translated into good news by the filtering effect of all the other bad news, is, of course, climate change. I know this because when I scan the daily headlines I always click on the articles about climate change in the hopes of hearing the good news that there is more bad news about climate change. And I know this because the people writing these climate change update pieces can barely contain their glee, too. Case in point, a recent Salon article reporting that the oceans are heating up more quickly than previously realized. (http://www.salon.com/2014/10/06/the_oceans_are_heating_up_a_lot_more_quickly_than_we_thought/) The article was subtitled “New data is bad news for anyone who hoped global warming was on hiatus,” but is understood by the Salon readership to actually mean “New data is good news for anyone who feared that global warming was on hiatus.” After explaining how the slowing of global warming is more than offset by a rise in the oceans’ temperatures “about 24 to 58 percent more quickly than models suggested,” the article quotes oceanographers Gregory Johnson and John M. Lyman’s assertion that “One could say that global warming is ocean warming.” (Oceanographers renaming global warming as ocean warming does sound a little bit like a football team’s offensive coordinator exclaiming that “the best defense is a good offense.”) From there, it is short work for article author Lindsay Abrams, whose byline identifies her as “reporting on all things sustainable,” to close by declaring that “In other words it (climate change) isn’t over. It’s just getting started.” Which, like her subtitle, comes off like appropriate handwringing about climate change, if, that is, one ignores the subjective heartbeat thrumming throughout the entire article. Subjectively speaking, Abrams closing thought is, quite simply, ecstatic.

This ecstasy is grounded in the political left’s understanding of climate change as the guarantor of the left’s belief that the future belongs to us. It is a vision grounded in the mythological narrative that the left has conflated with the brute facts of climate change. This mythology pictures climate change as the flames of late capitalism burning itself down, and then, rising from the ashes like a phoenix, voila, a new democratic socialism. Or anarcho-syndicalism, which is fine because it isn’t capitalism. As someone who traffics in this teleological fantasy as often as I scan the news headlines, “It’s just getting started” sounds like a battle cry of freedom. The fantasy hinges on the seemingly commonsensical logic that since it is abundantly obvious that globalized capitalism caused climate change, and since climate change is horrifically bad, then capitalism will at last be seen for the malignant cancer that it is and, at long last, be consigned to the dustbin of history.

The problem with this is that it ignores the first axiom of commonsense, which is that the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. Which makes it highly probable that capitalism will be able to succeed in turning climate change into yet another business opportunity, e.g. by commodifying “sustainability” via a “green economy.” This process is already in full swing at your local Whole Foods and Toyota Prius dealership. Which is not to say that eating organic or conserving energy are bad in and of themselves, but that, like recycling, they not only won’t save us, but will also pave the road to hell with good intentions. (That intention, of course, is a “free market economy” that works for all of us, which is akin to running on a platform of “Elitism for everyone!”, making us the gullible fools who really believe the carnival barker when he says of capitalism, “Step right up, everyone’s a winner!”) This is not to say that climate change won’t ultimately render the earth uninhabitable, but to say that climate change may not present a “limit to growth” until that rendering is a fait accompli. Two metaphors may help. The first is of a giant balloon that keeps expanding right up until the moment it has sucked in the very last drop of air. Or, if you prefer, the Blob, which continues expanding until it has consumed every last molecule.

In short, we should be seeking our own liberation, and hope that in the process we save the earth, as opposed to counting on the death of the earth to save and liberate us. The problem is that just as I can’t imagine any good news other than more climate change, we can’t think of anything we can do to liberate ourselves. Our challenge, then, in imagining our liberation is in thinking the inconceivable. We should ask ourselves, “What is an impossible future?”, and start there. And if we lose our nerve, recall that LeBron is already back in Cleveland. So, because it would only be appropriate to close by putting a paradoxical spin on Badiou’s events with a line inspired by a sports movie, Field of Dreams’ “If you build it, they will come,” I would say this:

If we can think it, the completely unpredictable and unforeseen event is inevitable.

Monday, February 17, 2014

Return to the Beginning

I had my first “Oh shit, this is really happening,” moment in regards to the fallout from climate change this week as three weather-related stories stacked up in my mind like three consecutive flights approaching Baltimore/Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport. In no particular order, the trifecta of scary weather is as follows:

• The American south, where winter is typically more of a fashion opportunity than an actual season (why do home sapiens look so good in layers?), is covered in up to an inch of ice, with nearly a half million homes out of power. And where “It’s not unreasonable to expect that Atlanta- sometimes known as ‘the city in a forest’- could lose a quarter of its trees in this storm.” (http://www.usatoday.com/story/weather/2014/02/12/atlanta-trees-ice-storm/5432571/)

• The rainiest winter in 250 years “has left parts of southern England under water,” where, it is interesting to note, the climate change doubting Conservative party Environment Secretary Owen Paterson has overseen a 40% cut in funding for adapting to climate change. (http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/feb/13/uk-floods-essential-guide)

• A record summer heat wave on the heels of “Australia’s hottest year on record.” And not just the humans are suffering: “Bats are said to be dropping from trees en masse and kangaroos are collapsing.” (http://rt.com/news/record-heat-australia-animals-388/)

Given my personal history, it is perhaps no surprise that, for me, climate change is finally starting to sink in. Baltimore has been my home now for over twenty years, but, if I may be permitted to deploy the cliché that “home is where the heart is,” I have at least three more: the American south and North Carolina in particular, where I was born and where the paternal side of my family still lives, and where one of the enduring loyalties of my life, Tarheel basketball, lives and breathes (I still have the certificate from my participation in Dean Smith’s basketball sleepaway camp which pronounces me a member of the Carolina basketball program forevermore; if the forevermore part wasn’t on the certificate it was implicit, and overrides my subsequent failure to obtain admission as a UNC undergraduate.); England, where I traveled with my father and Bucky (his Mom) during my eighth grade year to explore the Gaither family genealogy, and where, not inconsequentially, I visited Wimbledon’s Centre Court, a pilgrimage that left its lasting imprint in the form of my steadfast commitment to serve and volley tennis despite never once having set foot on the grass courts for which it (my serve and volley game) is ideally suited (I play hard court tennis, a sport built from the forehand up; that my forehand is roughly as reliable as the Millenium Falcon’s hyperdrive unit explains why, despite a semi-booming serve, a steady slice backhand, and a poor man’s McEnroe feel at the net, I have yet to beat Steve. Hope, though, springs eternal; I may not have a new forehand, but I do have a new racquet!); and Australia, especially Western Australia, where I spent my junior year abroad, and where, having gone to boarding school with my sister and then to college with two buddies from boarding school, I was, for the very first time in my life, alone. Making Australia my introduction into the (solo) art of dying.

Up until now my approach to news of climate change had been that of a faithful initiate into The Tao of Pooh:

“ ‘How… will you know what’s going on in the world?’ I said.
‘By going outside,’ said Pooh.
‘Er…well….’ (Click.) ‘Now just listen to this, Pooh.’
‘Thirty thousand people were killed today when five jumbo airliners collided over downtown Los Angeles…’ the Radio announced.
‘What does that tell you about the world?’ asked Pooh.
‘Hmm. You’re right.’ (Click.)”

It is, however, more difficult to ignore the news when it’s about one’s very own assorted Hundred Acre Woods, and even more so when one can catch the (bad) news simply ‘by going outside.’ So while, like Pooh, I remain very interested in what’s for breakfast, I am also increasingly inclined to sleep with one eye open and fixed upon the existential threat of climate change. (I would note, before moving on from The Tao of Pooh, that ‘five jumbo airliners collid(ing) over downtown Los Angeles…” is eerily similar to the events of 9/11, as if the author, Benjamin Hoff, foresaw the 21st Century’s foundational event; in clicking the narrative off at precisely this point, Hoff as prophet would seem to preemptively cancel the preemptive wars that followed, but really just descends into the ultimate solipsistic act of closing one’s eyes in order to undo the world beyond one’s eyelids. Taoism’ s Wu Wei, or not doing, is no excuse for not paying attention.)

The problem with recognizing climate change as an existential threat is that it’s not the first such threat to our species in this epoch when there have been enough of us around to weather even e.g. the Black Death. That problem has to do with the nature of that first threat, nuclear annihilation. Having staved off the most likely nuclear doomsday scenario, the escalation of the War between the United Sates and the Soviet Union from Cold to Hot, existential threats of the man-made variety, which climate change most certainly is, just don’t seem particularly threatening. We have already gazed right into Nietzsche’s abyss, it gazed back into us, and we didn’t blink.

But, re: climate change, the comfort taken from winning the Cold War is as false as a Hoff-ian sticking of one’s head in the sand. In taking this comfort we are making the same category mistake lamented in the old Valvoline commercials: “Motor oil is motor oil.” I.e. all existential threats are not created equal. Nuclear annihilation, unlike climate change, had a built in solution in the form of mutually assured destruction (MAD). Once both sides had enough nukes, neither side could ever use them. Nuclear weapons existed in order not to, twisting Shakespeare’s most famous line into “To be is not to be.” However irrational the stockpiles of nukes that could incinerate the planet umpteen times over appeared, the stockpiles existed precisely because the players involved were all rational actors.

But if the world gone MAD was essentially rational, then climate change is an altogether different form of madness: “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” This Narcotics Anonymous slogan fits the current form of our addiction to oil to a T (an addiction acknowledged by none other than George W. Bush!). That form is the expectation that we can go on consuming mass quantities of oil over and over again and get different results as long as we reduce, reuse, and recycle, which is like a heroin junky pinning his hopes on the needle exchange program. Harm reduction is well and good, but us oil junkies need to go cold turkey. Which isn’t hyperbole. A sustainable climate would require Americans to leave a carbon footprint just 3% its current size, which cuts close enough to cold turkey to count like so many horseshoes or hand grenades. (http://www.manicore.com/anglais/documentation_a/greenhouse/quota_GHG.html)

Narcotics Anonymous and its cousin Alcoholics Anonymous, with their emphasis on surrender to a higher power (Step 3), work for so many because, in the words of Carl Jung, “Sobriety requires a religious or spiritual experience or ‘conversion.’” Like cures like. Just so, addiction, an irrational disease, requires an irrational cure. And the varieties of religious experience, as documented by William James, meet precisely this criterion: “Your whole subconscious life, your impulses, your faiths, your needs, your divinations, have prepared the premises, of which your consciousness now feels the weight of the result; and something in you absolutely knows that that result must be truer than any logic-chopping rationalistic talk, however clever, that may contradict it.” This is no discredit to religious experience; if nothing succeeds like success, then nothing cures like a cure. The proof, as they say, is in the pudding.

The question, then, is where does climate change’s “irrational” cure lie? The various great spiritual traditions may offer a clue. In my own tradition, the clue reads thusly: “Truly I tell you, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it.” In the Tao Te Ching, as quoted in The Tao of Pooh, the clue reads “Return to the beginning; become a child again,” and something similar is likely to be found in each of the traditions. Following this lead in search of a cure for climate change brings us to a children’s picture book, the very first line of which is:

“I am part of all I see,
And all I see is part of me.”

It is, of course, all too easy to dismiss the book, All I See Is Part Of Me by Chara M. Curtis with illustrations by Cynthia Aldrich, as so much “New Age claptrap,” to borrow a phrase from Terry Eagleton. The beauty (or curse) of such labels is that they enable us to categorically dismiss entire schools of thought in one fell swoop, leaving our own Weltanschauung unquestioned and completely intact. The Weltanschauung in play here, the one that automatically labels “I am part of all I see, And all I see is part of me,” as daft, is that lynchpin of modern western civilization, Cartesian Dualism.

When Descartes, with his famed cogito ("I think, therefore I am") split the mind off from the body, he set in motion a way of “being in the world” that can be boiled down to the seemingly harmless two-letter word “in.” (Heidegger’s use of the term “being-in-the-world” tells us that much of contemporary western philosophy, far from being a “footnote to Plato,” is actually a paraphrase of Descartes). Take away the “in” and you take away Descartes. Take away the “in” and you are left with “being the world”; more precisely, you are left with “I am part of all I see, And all I see is part of me.” The bet here is that the choices one makes “in” the world will diverge from those made “as” the world.

As everyone knows, “The Lord Giveth, and the Lord taketh away.” Under the cogito’s lordship we have been blessed with the fruits of the scientific method, e.g. penicillin and electricity. It is nice to be able to turn on the lights, the heat and the internet while not having to worry about polio. But in the bargain, we are losing our ecosystem. It is also nice to have a planet to live on. But if our still-accelerating carbon footprint is any indication, the cogito’s signature accomplishment, the scientific method notwithstanding, is a great forgetting. We have, rather manifestly, forgotten the whole taketh away part of the equation. In our “addiction to oil” we are like a scratched record constantly (and, per Al Gore, “conveniently”) repeating “The Lord Giveth,” leaving the earth looking much like the mutilated stump at the end of The Giving Tree. In our devotion to the cogito we have “forgotten” that “the Lord taketh away,” even as the cogito’s scientific method reminds us that “for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.”

Which makes the cogito’s great forgetting more accurately a great repression (and climate change the return of the repressed). What we’ve repressed, what lies outside our current probables and possibles, is that “We are the World,” a proposition that can only be put forward in pop music and children’s books. (To the degree that “We are the World” worked, i.e. raised money for Live Aid, it had much more to do with our love for Michael Jackson than for our neighbor, much less our enemy. When I was in the second grade I wanted to be Michael Jackson, which meant being able to moonwalk, wear fabulous zippered jackets, and be adored by millions of fans, and had nothing to do with feeding millions of hungry people, many of whom, if “Weird” Al Jankovic’s cover of Jackson’s “Beat It” (i.e. “Eat it”) was to be trusted, lived in Japan.)

If one can define something by what it isn’t, than the meaning of “I think, therefore I am” is simply the negation of “I am part of all I see, And all I see is part of me,” giving us another answer to David Foster Wallace’s question, “What the hell is water?”:

“There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older fish swimming the other way, who nods at them and says ‘Morning, boys. How’s the water?’ And the two young fish swim on for a bit, and then eventually one of them looks over at the other and goes ‘What the hell is water?’”

Water, for our purposes here, is Cartesian dualism. For us land dwellers, it is the very air we breathe, which is why we literally choke on “I am part of all I see, And all I see is part of me.” As true believing Cartesians, it is noxious gas. The cure for climate change is hidden in plain sight in a children’s book because children are the last one’s left who haven’t yet internalized the cogito. Children, our only hope, are natural born (Cartesian) skeptics. If we “return to the beginning,” we just may find that “everything old is new again.”

Like Bugs Bunny, with Descartes and the cogito we took a wrong turn at Albequerque. Assuming we can all agree that the destruction of the biosphere is a wrong turn. It is always tempting to conclude that this was simply how things had to be, that this particular human journey was required if we were to learn the necessary lessons. But this way of thinking is a peculiar (convenient?) form of whitewashing which, more than anything, dishonors and disfigures the memories of those who have suffered, as if their suffering was some form of valiant human sacrifice on our behalf when in truth it was and remains a horror story. Not to mention the fact that it is yet unclear if we will learn the preordained lessons in time.

In Constantine’s Sword: The Church and the Jews, James Carroll analyzes the “two-thousand year course of the Church’s battle against Judaism” with the basic assumption that something went horribly wrong and, more radically, it could have gone very differently. Carroll looks to a past that might have been otherwise in order to stake a claim on a future that yet may be: “To ask what was the alternative to European Christianity’s hatred of Jews in the past is to assert that such hatred is not necessary in the future.” Following Carroll, we must refuse to paper over the disastrous legacy of the split between mind and body as some sort of necessary dialectical step. We must assert that it is this very split which now sees us fast approaching a biological tipping point like light accelerating towards the event horizon beyond which lies, inexorably, the black hole. Borrowing from Carroll, to ask what was the alternative to the Cartesian manipulation of the physical world in the past is to assert that such manipulation is not necessary in the future. If the future has always belonged to those asking the right questions, then whether or not we have a human future depends on being prepared to ask just this. And fast.